Pirata participates in the Pirate of the Year contest on Barracuda Island. Non-pirates are not allowed to participate, but a curious Capitano sneaks over to get a look at what they're doing. Caught in the act, he is also accused of stealing a necklace. When Pirata finds out that Dodo the Devious is the real thief, the rules change on Barracuda Island: from now on, non-pirates may also participate in the search for the Great Treasure.